There's a debate about which kind of exercise is best for diabetics, and at the University of Calgary a diabetes specialist has found that aerobic and/or weight training improves blood sugar levels, and that the improvements are twice as good with combined aerobic and weight training.
"Our study demonstrates that people with Type 2 diabetes who want to maximize their glucose control, and reduce their risk of long-term complications, should consider a combination of both aerobic and resistance training like weight lifting," said Sigal, associate professor in the faculties of medicine and kinesiology at the University of Calgary. "I suspected that high intensity weight training could help improve blood sugar levels in people with diabetes, and might also improve vitality and quality of life. That's why we decided to do this study."
The study included 251 people with Type 2 diabetes.
They were split into three groups, one doing aerobic exercise, one weight training, and one doing both exercises. Those doing both exercises reduced their A1c reading by about 1-percentage point, whereas the single exercise groups reduced their A1c by half a percentage point each group. Thus the basis of the claim that doing both is "twice as good".
It might actually be better than twice as good since weight training restores lean muscle mass which has other benefits as we age, such as maintaining a higher metabolism and thus keeping us in shape for the same calorie intake, and being able to use our muscles and bodies more effectively in our normal lifestyle.
Aerobic exercise training directly improves blood glucose levels and through that leads to a reduced risk of diabetes-related complications. In addition, aerobic exercise training has been found to improve cardiovascular risk factors associated with type 2 diabetes, such as lipid profile, hypertension and abdominal obesity (visceral fat and the waistline). Muscular strength training is also associated with improved glycemic control and the effects of aerobic and resistance exercise on glycemic control are additive, as reported above.
Progressive resistance training for older adults with type 2 diabetes has been found to increased lean muscle mass, reduced systolic blood pressure, and decreased body fat mass - all very positive outcomes. Furthermore the benefits of such training linger for at least 6 months after such exercise routines, especially in higher lean body mass and muscle strength, although not necessarily in fat mass or glycemic control.
What is particularly important is that diet without exercise and particularly resistance exercise has been found to have negative effects on bone mass in older adult diabetics. When diet was combined with resistance exercise this bone mass loss was not noted. Since some of the bone mass loss was found to have occurred in the femoral neck and lumbar spine this is highly undesirable for older people. Hence, in older, overweight adults with type 2 diabetes, dietary modification should be combined with progressive resistance training to optimize the effects on body composition without having a negative effect on bone health.
So what about just resistance exercise?
Good question, since it appears that resistance training seems to have more benefits, including the maintenance of bone health. And now we get to contradictory research results.
At the Wilhelminenspital in Vienna researchers found (2007) that resistance training produced significant benefits in blood glucose and insulin in type 2 diabetics, but that no significant changes resulted from an aerobic endurance training group. Furthermore baseline levels of total cholesterol, low-density lipoprotein cholesterol, and triglyceride levels were significantly reduced and high-density lipoprotein cholesterol was significantly increased in the strength training group; in contrast, no such changes were seen in the aerobic endurance training group.
They concluded straight out:
Strength training was more effective than endurance training in improving glycemic control. With the added advantage of an improved lipid profile, we conclude that strength training may play an important role in the treatment of T2D.
Just for completeness, and reference, this endurance training was planned with an intensity of maximal oxygen consumption of 60% and a frequency beginning at 15 min and advancing to a maximum of 30 min 3x/week.
The Canadian study didn't measure lipids, the cholesterol factors, so we can't compare the two studies on that basis. The Canadians also measured a group doing one or the other or both types of exercise, whereas the Vienna study only compared the two different types of exercise. That said, the Canadian study did report positive results for the group just doing aerobic training, whereas the Vienna study reported no benefits.
Just to throw in more "research" on this debate, also in 2007 the AHEPA Hospital in Greece measured the results of aerobic endurance training on 60 overweight type 2 diabetics and found that in comparison with a control group (no exercise) the exercise-treated patients "improved glucose control, lipid profile, exercise capacity (VO2 peak) and exhibited decreased insulin resistance and systolic BP considerably". And importantly the Greek researchers measured and found improvements in anti-inflammatory protection in the blood vessels, which means improved insulin sensitivity, in the exercise group.
What's the best plan for adult diabetics?
On the basis of the potential maintenance of bone mass, and the blood glucose and cholesterol improvements as reported above, it would seem that resistance training is the best maintenance exercise for type 2 diabetics.
Whether it is the best starting exercise, for those newly diagnosed and wishing to lose weight, or just starting exercise with the initial goal of weight loss, I'm not sure. In that case it may be more effective to start with a food plan and associated aerobic exercise - to avoid losing lean muscle mass - and to gradually incorporate some resistance training into the program to build muscle mass and to maintain bone density.
The key thing to take into account is that such exercises need to form a part of a lifestyle change and a long-term training schedule. When you are diabetic it is your lifetime exercise profile which will provide the answers to some of your diabetes management challenges.
Is there a adult diabetes item that you think we should feature? Email tips@diabetorati.com. Thanks!
Visit our customized Amazon shopping mall for diabetic books, food, and fun !
Recent Comments